The Blog

Gusto Payroll Software: Our In-Depth Review

Managing payroll is a critical yet complex task for any business, requiring a reliable solution that can handle compliance, employee payments, and record-keeping with ease. Gusto Payroll Software has gained popularity for its user-friendly interface and comprehensive features, making it a go-to choice for many businesses. This Gusto Payroll Software Review is not compensated; however, please note that there are affiliate links in the post. As with any software, Gusto comes with its own set of pros and cons. This review will explore what we love about Gusto and the areas where it could improve.

What We Love

Compliance and Reporting: Simplifying Legal Obligations

Gusto stands out with its robust compliance and reporting capabilities. Navigating the maze of federal, state, and local tax regulations can be daunting for any business. Gusto simplifies this process by automatically calculating, filing, and paying payroll taxes. It also generates year-end forms such as W-2s and 1099s, ensuring that businesses remain compliant and avoid costly penalties. This feature alone can save businesses significant time and stress, allowing them to focus on their core operations.

Direct Deposit for Employees and Contractors: Efficient Payment Processing

The direct deposit feature in Gusto ensures timely and accurate payments for both employees and contractors. This functionality boosts employee satisfaction and trust by eliminating the delays and errors associated with manual payment methods. For contractors, who often work on tight schedules, the reliability of direct deposit is particularly beneficial, fostering better professional relationships.

One-Stop-Shop for Employee Records: Centralized Information Access

Gusto offers a comprehensive employee portal where employees can access their pay stubs, tax documents, and benefits information all in one place. This centralized hub empowers employees to manage their own information, reducing the administrative burden on HR departments. It also promotes transparency, as employees can easily access and review their records whenever needed.

Things We Don’t Love

Monthly Fees: A Potential Burden for Small Organizations

Despite its extensive features, Gusto’s cost can be a significant drawback for smaller businesses. With monthly fees ranging from $40 to $60 depending on the plan, the cost can quickly add up, especially for companies with modest payrolls. For startups and small enterprises operating on tight budgets, these fees might seem prohibitive, pushing them to look for more affordable alternatives.

Upsell Pitches: Interruptions in User Experience

A frequent criticism of Gusto is the regular upsell pitches within the platform. While it’s understandable that Gusto wants to promote its additional services, constant suggestions to upgrade or add features can be distracting. Users who simply want to manage their payroll without interruption might find these pitches frustrating, detracting from the overall user experience.

Integration Limitations: Incompatibility with Non-Preferred Vendors

Gusto’s integration capabilities are somewhat limited, particularly with non-preferred vendors. While it integrates well with its preferred partners, it doesn’t offer the same level of compatibility with other tools. This can be a significant drawback for businesses that use a diverse suite of software and need seamless integration to streamline their operations. The lack of flexibility can lead to inefficiencies and additional manual work, which goes against the convenience that Gusto aims to provide.

Time Tracking: Basic Compared to Other Solutions

While Gusto does offer basic time tracking features, there are other solutions on the market that provide more advanced and intuitive tools. For businesses with complex timekeeping needs, such as multiple shifts or remote workers, Gusto’s time tracking may not be sufficient. This limitation might necessitate the use of supplementary software, which adds to the overall cost and complexity.

Bottom Line: Why We Recommend Gusto Payroll Software

Gusto Payroll Software offers numerous features that simplify payroll management, enhance compliance, and improve employee satisfaction. Its strengths in compliance and reporting, direct deposit functionality, and centralized employee records make it an attractive choice for many businesses. However, the relatively high monthly fees, frequent upsell pitches, integration challenges, and basic time tracking features are important considerations.

Ultimately, the decision to use Gusto will depend on your specific business needs and priorities. For those who prioritize robust compliance support and ease of use, Gusto may be worth the investment. However, smaller businesses and those requiring extensive integrations or advanced time tracking might find better value elsewhere. As with any business decision, it’s crucial to assess the trade-offs and select the solution that best aligns with your operational requirements and budget constraints.

That said, our experience with Gusto has been overwhelmingly positive. We have used Gusto for nearly 10 years, managing payroll for teams as small as two and as large as twenty. The software has consistently delivered reliable service and comprehensive features that have streamlined our payroll processes. If you sign up through our link, you’ll receive a $100 Visa gift card when you run your first payroll. In our Gusto payroll review, we highly recommend Gusto for businesses or campaigns seeking a dependable and feature-rich payroll solution.

Quick note! Some links in our blog are affiliate links. If you click and buy, we might earn a commission for sharing our favorite products – no extra cost to you. It’s like a win-win!

Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest blog posts and all of our favorite tips and tricks, straight to your inbox – no spam, just the good stuff.

Love what you're reading?
Let's stay in touch!

Subscribe to our newsletter